#DoNowUPigs Reflection

Do Now U:

Should pigs be used to grow human organs for people who needs transplants? Why or why not? 

After reading this KQED Learning – Do Now U article, I was very intrigued at the thought that studies like these are being done in modern science. Scientists are now able to insert a human stem cell into a pig embryo, and study this unborn fetus weeks into gestation. If human organs could be grown in a pig and used in transplant surgeries for all different kinds of organs, the amount of lives that would be saved is truly unfathomable. At the current rate, too many human lives are lost on a daily basis due to failing and weak organs that cannot be replaced in time. However, this could all change in short order. So what is the hold up? Well… this is where ethics comes into play and really makes me ponder the pros and cons of this amazing scientific breakthrough.

organize_logo_square

This new discovery in modern science is coming at a cost today due to the major ethical discussion it sparks. One of the biggest concerns is that if these pigs that are carrying embryos with growing human stem cells, there is the possibility that these human cells could develop in the wrong place. For example, if a pig were to develop mutated human organ or even a human brain, many problems could arise in the practicality and humanity in the entire project itself. Another issue of concern is that if scientists were to successfully grow healthy, human organs inside these pigs, when would the killing of these innocent animals stop? Would the successful scientists be money driven rather than looking at the big picture of saving lives? Many ethical questions such as these come to my mind just as they would anyone’s mind pondering what this could mean for saving the lives of sick humans, while maintaining the humanity for these animals.

So if I were to state my answer to this very complicated question, I would more or less agree with the pace at which this study is going currently. Science is taking human growth in pigs very seriously due to all of the error there is room for. At the same time, I do believe if scientists have already gotten this far, that they can maintain control of it and eventually grow human organs to be transplanted into humans for a renewed chance at life. I have the hope that in the end, both the humans and the animals will be kept in mind, and not lead to the horrific possibilities being questioned in ethics. Science is magnificent, just as human nature and animals are, and they all rely on each other.

*Images labeled for noncommercial reuse*

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “#DoNowUPigs Reflection

  1. Hey Taylor, I really enjoyed reading your blog post! I totally agree with your concerns and I was especially interested in which you said about scientists being “money driven” since discoveries can bring about great profit (regardless of their ethical stance). I also really appreciated what you pointed out about how cautious scientists need to be since there is so much room for error in scientific discovery such as this! Personally, I would like to see scientists find a way to save human lives without ending the lives of innocent animals. Overall, great job!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I completely agree with Taylor’s argument. Saving another human’s life without taking another is really breathtaking and should definitely be pursued. But I believe that this study should take its time with no rush. I also agree with the idea that, if this were to successfully be accomplished, where would the killing of these pigs stop? Especially if this becomes about money instead of helping other people. In my opinion, this experiment reolves around Bioethic Principle of Justice. Even though we are helping to save human lives, we are still killing off another, the one of an innocent pig. The principle of Justice is built on fairness. Using another species to benefit ours, according to this principle, makes it look a little inhumane. That “a fair distribution of benefits and costs across all people affected by a particular ethical issue”. How can this be addressed if a whole species does not benefit at all. In my opinion, this study is very innovative and incredible, and should be studied. But I can see how this experiment brings up many ethical issues. But, like Taylor said, if the scientists can keep a lid on this experiment and control it, I think it would be a really groundbreaking discovery.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Taylor, I really liked your closing sentence, Science is magnificent, just as human nature and animals are, and they all rely on each other.” What a graceful writeup on how much you respect human life and longevity through scientific intervention, while respecting the life of animals, and how it is worth taking the time to preserve both.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s